I waffle between Asylum or Ten Thousand Fists being Disturbed's best album, but it's pretty much unquestioned that this was the last time they were such a self-assured band. Whatever your thoughts about their last couple albums are, the post-Asylum hiatus changed the band significantly and I don't predict that we're going to get another album from Disturbed that I'm going to like nearly as much as Asylum.
Outlaw Gentlemen & Shady Ladies, Volbeat (April 5, 2013)
They say there's nothing quite like your first... Outlaw Gentlemen & Shady Ladies was the album where I decided to give Volbeat a chance and I fell in love with their style. Seal the Deal & Let's Boogie would also have a pretty good shot at being one of my favourite albums of the decade, but they both fell just short of the top 10. Still, I love the band so much that I had to at least give them an honourable mention.
10) We're Just Really Excited to Be Here, Countless Thousands (June 4, 2011)
Countless Thousands' debut album is such a joy to listen to. Their brand of enthusiastic nerd rock is infectious and energetic from the outset and there is so much variety and experimentation that it never gets boring. Want a pirate rock song? Try "A Pirate's Shanty". Want something political? You'll love "The Patriot". How about a version of "The Devil Went Down to Georgia", but rewritten to be about bassist Davey Munch battling Satan? Try "The Devil and Davey Munch", it's amazing. There's even stuff like "No Contest", where there is no instrumentation, only vocal layering which gives the song an interesting and haunting feel. On top of all of this, the songwriting is all top-notch, with one exception - personally, I just can't stand "The Asskickers' Union", a sickly-sweet love song which is just too goddamn happy for my tastes. It's not like that's a major blemish though on a 16 track album and there are plenty of other styles and standout tracks that it's easily washed away.
9) of Beauty and Rage, Red (February 24, 2015)
Red were a band that I got into with their first two albums, but gave up on after their next two albums were very disappointing. Imagine my joy then when they managed to not only course correct and return to form on their fifth album, but they actually managed to put out their best album yet. of Beauty and Rage sees Red firing on all cylinders, putting out an album which is equal parts heavy, haunting, epic and beautiful in various measures. It certainly feels like a Red album, but there's a maturity to it and everything has clearly been crafted painstakingly. At this point, I'd consider of Beauty and Rage to be Red's magnum opus. They have set the bar very high for themselves going forward, but they've shown that they know what it takes to come back. If Red ever manage to put out something that can match this album I would be delightfully surprised.
8) Dark Before Dawn, Breaking Benjamin (June 23, 2015)
In my opinion, Dark Before Dawn is Breaking Benjamin's best album. Perhaps this is because I got into the band pretty late into their career, but as far as I'm concerned it is by far their best overall. You'd be justified in saying that Breaking Benjamin just cover the same ground over and over again, but Dark Before Dawn is the best execution of this by far. All of their previous albums were uneven at best, even ones I genuinely like such as Dear Agony or Phobia. However, Dark Before Dawn is great from start to finish, with no track being weak or feeling like filler (other than the mood-setting, instrumental opening and closing tracks, but they're harmless in my opinion). On the contrary, there are so many standout tracks here, from "Failure", to "Angel's Fall", to "Close to Heaven" and "Ashes of Eden", all of which show off Benjamin Burnley's fantastic voice and make you want to sing along.
7) Carolus Rex, Sabaton (May 22, 2012)
While Heroes might be the point when Sabaton hit the peak of their popularity, its predecessor Carolus Rex is still the height of the band's talents. It's perhaps their most focused and personal work ever, detailing the rise and fall of the Swedish empire. In fact, it's so interesting and compelling that it has taught me more about this period of time in Europe than any history class I've ever taken. THe songs straight into history. A particular highlight in this regard is "A Lifetime of War", which make you feel how awful a decade-long war is, and then pulls the rug out and reveals that this war would go on for another two decades. Songs like "The Carolean's Prayer", "Carolus Rex" and "Ruina Imperii" all demonstrate the religious fanaticism of the time, how it was used to control men and dehumanize others. "The Carolean's Prayer" in particular is easily one of the best songs of Sabaton's career. Oh and I would be remiss to forget that Carolus Rex also has some amazing B-sides, most notably a cover of Amon Amarth's "Twilight of the Thunder God". When I was in university and this song came out, I would play it on repeat over and over again and try to death growl along. It's so good and the fact that it's a B-side better than what most bands can manage to put onto full albums is insane.
6) Marrow of the Spirit, Agalloch (November 23, 2010)
Most of the albums on this list are my favourite by their respective bands. With that said, I feel it's worth emphasizing that Marrow of the Spirit is actually only my third favourite Agalloch album - seriously, if you haven't listened to them before, do it. Agalloch tend to dabble in atmospheric doom metal with clear nature- and pagan-inspirations to each of their songs. Marrow of the Spirit is perhaps their rawest album in that regard. Having come off of two fairly polished albums, Agalloch were looking for a grittier sound and so opted to record Marrow of the Spirit on vintage analog equipment. The difference in production quality is immediately obvious when you compare Marrow of the Spirit to The Mantle or Ashes Against the Grain, but it works very well within Agalloch's sound. The album immediately sets the tone with "They Escaped the Weight of Darkness", a sombre mood-setter which is almost entirely composed of a cello and a recording of water running. From there, each of the remaining 5 tracks is just incredibly well-composed doom metal, equal parts sombre and epic, ranging in lengths from 9:40 to a staggering 17:34 on "Black Lake Niðstång". "Black Lake Niðstång" is a particular highlight for me - it certainly feels like a 17 minute song, but it goes through so many changes throughout that it never stagnates. Marrow of the Spirit might not be Agalloc's most accessible album, but it's certainly one that gets better the more you listen to it.
5) Through Glass Eyes, At Dawn's Edge (September 30, 2017)
Oh hey, the first pick from one of my annual album rankings! As I said back then, Through Glass Eyes is ambitious, diverse, mature and has impeccable production values, all of which are even more impressive when you consider that this is not only a debut album but also an independent release! They also don't fit into cliches - many female-fronted, symphonic/melodic metal bands can get dismissed for sounding like Evanescence-wannabes, but At Dawn's Edge have more maturity to their songwriting and singing which gives them their own unique flavour. It's a fantastic debut album and I've been eagerly awaiting its follow-up ever since. Owing to the independent nature of this band, I would implore you to check them out if you have not yet, they're seriously this good.
4) Blood, In This Moment (August 14, 2012)
In This Moment are unquestionably one of my favourite bands right now. Every album they put out has its own unique flavour, but in my opinion Blood is clearly their best overall. It maintains the band's metalcore edge while dipping into more experimentation to make the album feel a bit more unique than its more standard-metal predecessor, A Star-Crossed Wasteland. Of course, experimentation doesn't mean much if the music isn't great, but luckily Blood has so many good songs that it's practically a greatest hits album. "Blood", "Adrenalize" and "Whore" are all top-notch and kick the album into high gear right out of the gate. They're not the only highlights though, there's also the fantastic "Burn" which shows off Maria Brink's ability to go from melodic vocals to blistering screams. Tracks like "Beast Within", "The Blood Legion" and the haunting "11:11" also bear mentioning and, like Carolus Rex, the B-side cover of Nine Inch Nail's "Closer" is also an absolute treat. My fiance loves it... and I'll let you fill in the blanks from there. Blood is also notable for "sexing up" In This Moment (to the point where they would feel the need to address it on their next album in the song "Sex Metal Barbie"). The album deals with themes of abuse and manipulation, but it always reclaims sex and turns it into something empowering. It gives this album a bit of a sultry, even kinky, edge that I really enjoy and gives it a much different vibe than any other metal band I listen to.
3) Wait for the Siren, Project 86 (August 21, 2012)
Wait for the Siren came out at a time when it looked like Project 86 were about to implode - after 7 very solid albums, their guitarist, drummer and bassist all quit the band, only leaving frontman Andrew Schwab to continue on. Luckily for us, Andrew Schwab was always the primary, most dominant creative force in the band, so the loss of the other band members didn't completely sink Project 86 (that said, Schwab's overbearing control might actually have been why the other band members quit, they wanted to experiment more and he wouldn't let them, or so the rumours say). Having also quit Tooth and Nail Records in favour of crowdfunding, Schwab was free to rebuild the band in whatever way he saw fit, and Wait for the Siren is a fantastic mixture of old and new. Right off the bat, the band shows off some of this new creative expression with "Fall, Goliath, Fall", which features such distinctive instruments as uillean pipes, mandolin and hammer dulcimer. That said, these additions to Project 86's sound are just that - additions. The band is still as heavy as they ever were, as shown off in tracks such as "The Crossfire Gambit". Songwriting has always been Project 86's greatest strength and Wait for the Siren is no exception, with every track being diverse and interesting in their own regard. My personal favourite track on the album is the rousing "Take the Hill", easily one of the best tracks in Project 86's history. While Drawing Black Lines will probably always be my favourite Project 86 album, Wait for the Siren is easily my second favourite, which is pretty incredible considering that they haven't had a bad album in their lengthy career.
2) Eat the Elephant, A Perfect Circle (April 20, 2018)
Oh hey, another pick from my annual album rankings! Eat the Elephant really impressed me last year. Nearly every track is expertly crafted and has something to say, from the hopeful title track, to political and social commentary in tracks such as "The Contrarian", "The Doomed" and "TalkTalk". The particular highlight though is "So Long, and Thanks For All the Fish" a song which is apocalyptic and beautiful at the same time (to the point where it's probably going to end up getting played at my wedding... seriously). While the second half of the album is weaker than the first half, the fact that this album still managed to take the spot of my 2nd favourite album of the decade should go to show that that doesn't lower it in my estimation too much. The stuff that's here is just too damn good to pass up.
1) Devotion, Anberlin (October 15, 2013)
I love Anberlin. When they released their 6th album, Vital, I thought that it was almost as good as the band's fan favourite, Cities. However, just over a year later, the band reissued the album as Devotion, adding 3 new tracks and 4 B-sides to the original album and retooling the tracklist somewhat. This was, in my opinion, enough to put Devotion over the top to be the clear best album in the band's history. Vital already boasted some great music, such as the aptly-titled opener "Self-Starter", "Other Side", "Orpheum" and the absolutely fantastic "God, Drugs & Sex". You'd think that throwing a bunch of new songs and B-sides into an already-completed album might mess with the flow of the music, but the new additions are all solid and more than good enough to stand side-by-side with the existing tracks, although the best is definitely "IJSW". Devotion was by far my favourite album of the 2010s, I knew for sure going into this list that it was going to be my #1.
And that's it for my favourite albums of the 2010s. Tune in soon when I go through the best movies of the 2010s!